Landlord guide

How to Screen Tenants in Ontario (Legally and Fairly)

House keys handed over to a new tenant after screening

Quick answer: Good tenant screening in Ontario means checking credit, income, landlord references and ID with the applicant’s written consent, and applying the same fair criteria to everyone. The Ontario Human Rights Code bans discrimination, so focus on whether the applicant can pay rent and care for the home.

Why screening is worth the effort

A problem tenancy can mean months of unpaid rent, repair costs and time at the Landlord and Tenant Board. A careful, consistent screening process is the best protection a landlord has.

Step 1: Set clear, written criteria

Decide before you advertise what you will look for, such as income compared with rent, credit history and references. Use the same criteria for every applicant and keep notes.

Step 2: Collect a complete application

  • Full name and contact details
  • Current and previous addresses and landlords
  • Employment and income details
  • Written consent to a credit check
  • Photo ID (view it; avoid keeping copies you do not need)

Step 3: Verify, do not assume

  • Run a credit report with consent
  • Call previous landlords, not just the current one
  • Confirm employment and income
  • Check that names and details match across documents

What you cannot do

Under the Ontario Human Rights Code, you cannot refuse a tenant because of race, ancestry, place of origin, colour, ethnic origin, citizenship, creed, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, age, marital or family status, disability, or receipt of public assistance. You also cannot refuse someone just because they have children. A “no pets” clause in a lease is void for most residential tenancies, although condo rules can restrict pets.

Step 4: Sign the Ontario Standard Lease

Most residential tenancies must use the Ontario Standard Form of Lease. Give the tenant a copy within 21 days of signing. You can collect a last month’s rent deposit (up to one month’s rent) and a refundable key deposit, but not a damage deposit.

Need help? Sana Rentals manages rental properties in Hamilton, Burlington, Brantford, London, Niagara and GTA West. Get a free rental analysis or call 289-639-9595.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Check the Landlord and Tenant Board or a licensed paralegal or lawyer for your situation.

Find out what your property could earn

Get a free, no-obligation rental analysis. We will review your property, compare it with local rents, and tell you plainly what to expect.